Impeding Breath or Circulation in Austin: What the State Must Prove and What a First Offense Faces
Few accusations in a family violence case move faster or weigh more than an allegation of choking or strangulation. In Texas the charge is called impeding breath or circulation. It turns what would otherwise be a misdemeanor assault into a third-degree felony, and it can be filed after a single argument with no prior record and no visible injury. People searching for it usually want three answers: what the law actually requires, what a first offense faces and what can be done. Our Austin domestic violence attorney team can answer them for your case once we have seen the report and the records.
This guide covers the wording of the statute, what “impeding” does and does not include, the punishment and the situations that raise it, how a first offense is usually handled, the medical and other evidence, the defenses we examine, the charges that travel with it, protective orders and bond conditions, the effect on firearms, custody and your record, and the first steps to take. We also set right several claims about this charge that circulate online, some of which appeared on an earlier version of this page.
What Section 22.01 Says About Impeding Breath or Circulation
The charge is not a separate statute. It is a way of committing a family violence assault under Section 22.01 of the Penal Code, and it works like this:
- The base offense. Assault by intentionally, knowingly or recklessly causing bodily injury to another person is a Class A misdemeanor.
- The felony route. Under Section 22.01(b)(2)(B), the offense is a third-degree felony when it is committed against a person in a family, household or dating relationship, as the Family Code defines those terms, by intentionally, knowingly or recklessly impeding the normal breathing or circulation of the blood. The statute names two methods: applying pressure to the person’s throat or neck, or blocking the person’s nose or mouth.
- The mental state. The statute includes recklessness. Intent to stop anyone’s breathing is not required; knowing of a substantial risk and ignoring it is enough.
- The relationship. The felony route applies only when the relationship element is met. Without it, the same act is charged as an ordinary assault.
Websites often describe the offense as “any action that impedes breathing or blood flow.” The statute is narrower. It names pressure to the throat or neck and blocking the nose or mouth. A hand on the chest, a hold on the arms or a shove does not fit those words, even if the other person says they could not catch their breath.
Penalties and What Raises Them
The range depends on the facts and your record:
- Third-degree felony. Under Section 12.34 of the Penal Code the punishment is imprisonment for 2 to 10 years, plus an optional fine not above $10,000. Most first-offense cases fall in this bracket.
- Second-degree felony. Section 22.01(b-3) moves the offense to a range of 2 to 20 years when three things are present: the relationship, impeding breath or circulation and an earlier conviction of a listed offense against a person in that kind of relationship. The listed offenses include offenses under Chapter 22, offenses under Chapter 19, Sections 20.03, 20.04, 21.11 and 25.11, and violations of a protective order based on family violence. A deferred adjudication counts as a conviction for this purpose, and so does a conviction in another state with substantially similar elements.
- Aggravated assault. If the State alleges serious bodily injury or the use of a deadly weapon, it can charge aggravated assault under Section 22.02, a second-degree felony. It is a first-degree felony when a deadly weapon is used and serious bodily injury is caused to a person in a family, household or dating relationship. Section 22.01 allows the State to prosecute conduct that fits both statutes under either or both.
- A family violence finding. When the court determines that an assault involved family violence, Article 42.013 of the Code of Criminal Procedure requires an affirmative finding in the judgment. That finding carries consequences described below.
Some websites list additional enhancements, such as the presence of children or a “deadly weapon” add-on. Section 22.01 does not provide for those. A prosecutor may still use those facts to argue for a heavier sentence or to file another charge.
What a First Offense Faces
A first offense carries the same range as any other third-degree felony. There is no separate, lighter grade for someone with no record. What a clean record changes is the range of outcomes a prosecutor or court will consider:
- Dismissal or a reduction. A case can end in dismissal when the proof is weak, or in a reduction to misdemeanor assault. A reduction is the prosecutor’s decision, and it depends on the injuries, the evidence and the position of the person who made the report.
- Deferred adjudication. Article 42A.102 does not exclude Section 22.01 from deferred adjudication community supervision, so the law allows it in a proper case. If you complete the term, the case can be dismissed without a final conviction. Many family violence cases carry conditions such as a battering intervention program.
- Community supervision from the court. Article 42A.054(a) lists offenses for which the court cannot grant supervision, and neither Section 22.01 nor Section 22.02 is listed. A deadly weapon finding, though, would take that option away.
- Required terms. When a court grants supervision for a Title 5 offense that it finds involved family violence, Article 42A.504 requires a $100 fine paid to a family violence center and allows an order to attend a battering intervention program or counseling.
- Trial or prison. A case that cannot be resolved on acceptable terms can be tried, and a conviction can bring a prison sentence within the range.
No lawyer can tell you at the first meeting which of these will happen, and having no record does not mean probation is assured. What we can do is study the evidence, point out where the State is strong or weak and lay out each option with its cost.
The Evidence in an Impeding Breath Case
These cases often rest on a few kinds of proof, and each can be tested:
- Physical findings. Marks, bruising, tiny red spots in the eyes or face, a hoarse voice or pain on swallowing may be documented. They may also be absent, and their absence is a fact the jury hears. The statute asks whether breathing or circulation was impeded, not whether a mark was left.
- Medical records. An emergency room visit, an exam by a forensic nurse or a follow-up appointment can support or contradict the account. We obtain the full records and look at timing, what the person reported and what the examiner found.
- The 911 call and body camera. The caller’s words, voice and demeanor and the first officers’ observations often differ from later statements.
- Photographs and messages. Photos taken that night, texts sent before and after and social media posts can matter as much as the medical file.
- The accounts themselves. The person who made the report and any other witness are the main source on what the hands did and for how long.
The Penal Code defines bodily injury broadly enough that pain can qualify, so a lack of marks does not end a case, and the State must still connect the injury to the act described in the statute.
Defenses We Examine
Which defenses apply depends on the evidence and on what each person says happened. We begin with these questions:
- Was the relationship element met? The felony route requires a family, household or dating relationship as the Family Code defines it. If the facts do not fit the definition, the charge may drop to a misdemeanor.
- Where were the hands? Pressure to the throat or neck, or blocking the nose or mouth, is what the statute names. Contact elsewhere, or a push or hold, is not the same thing.
- Was the breathing or circulation actually impeded? The statute speaks of impeding the normal breathing or circulation of the blood. We look at what the person could do during and after the incident, such as speaking, calling out or leaving.
- What was the mental state? Because recklessness is included, an accident claim has to address risk as well as intent. We review how the contact happened and what you knew.
- Self-defense or defense of another. If you acted to protect yourself or someone else from harm, justification under Chapter 9 of the Penal Code may be raised. It is a legal question that depends heavily on the facts, and we evaluate it early.
- Is the account reliable? Reports of this kind sometimes surface during a custody or divorce dispute or after a breakup. Inconsistent statements, timing, messages sent afterward and what the 911 recording shows are all relevant.
- Is the proof thin? A report with no medical file, no photographs, no recording and no witness beyond the person who called may fall short of what the State must prove.
Charges That Often Travel With It
An impeding breath arrest rarely produces only one count. It is usually filed with an assault family violence charge for the same incident, and may come with interference with an emergency call when the allegation is that a phone was taken or a call was cut off. Each count has its own range, and the State may offer to dismiss one in exchange for a plea to another. Any offer gets measured against the full case, because a plea to a lesser count may still carry a family violence finding.
Emergency Protection Orders and Bond Conditions
The first court appearance often decides where you can live and whom you can contact. Under Article 17.292, a magistrate must issue an emergency protection order when a family violence arrest involves serious bodily injury, or a deadly weapon used or shown during an assault. In other cases the magistrate has discretion. The order lasts 61 to 91 days in the serious category and 31 to 61 days otherwise. Article 17.49 lets a court add bond conditions, including stay-away distances from a home, job or school, GPS monitoring and a bar on tracking the other person’s property. Breaking an order or a condition can bring a new charge. Our page on violation of a protective order explains how that works. These restrictions remain in force until a court changes them in writing, whatever the other person says, and a term that goes beyond the facts can be challenged by motion.
Firearms, Custody and Your Record
The effects of a conviction reach well beyond the sentence, and several of them depend on whether the case ends in a conviction or a dismissal:
- Firearms. Under Section 46.04(a) of the Penal Code, a convicted felon who possesses a firearm commits an offense for five years after release from confinement or supervision, whichever ends later, and afterward anywhere other than the premises where the person lives. Federal law has separate firearm rules that we review with you. The Texas offense is explained in our guide to prohibited weapon possession charges.
- Custody and visitation. Section 153.004 of the Family Code requires a court deciding conservatorship to consider evidence of family violence, rules out joint managing conservatorship where the evidence is credible that one parent has abused the other repeatedly, and restricts possession and access in some cases. An arrest is not a finding, but a pending case can shape a custody case in Austin, so we coordinate the two.
- Nondisclosure. Do not count on it. Government Code Section 411.074 forbids nondisclosure when the offense involved family violence and also when the court enters an affirmative family violence finding. The assumption on many sites that a completed deferred adjudication can be sealed is wrong for these cases.
- Expunction. A dismissal or an acquittal can make a record eligible for clearing. Our page on expunction and nondisclosure in Austin covers the options.
- Immigration and licensing. A felony conviction can affect a noncitizen’s status and a professional license. The details depend on the person, so tell us at the first meeting, and any plea can be reviewed with the immigration and licensing consequences in mind.
What This Means for Your Case in Travis County
- Have no contact with the other person about the incident, the charge or the case, whether directly, through friends or through social media, and follow every no-contact term.
- Write down what happened as you remember it, including where each of you was, what was said and who else was there. Keep it for your lawyer.
- If you have any injury of your own, such as scratches or bruises, photograph it and get it documented. If you took any photographs or messages that night, keep them.
- Say nothing about the incident to officers, to relatives of the other person or to anyone online, and post nothing.
- Obey every release condition, including GPS or check-ins, and attend each court date. Venue follows the location of the incident, so a case can land in Williamson or Hays County instead.
- Do not move, sell or give away firearms without talking to us first, and do not discard or edit your phone, messages or social media.
- Hold off on any plea or deferred adjudication offer until your lawyer has reviewed the report, the 911 recording, any body camera video, the medical records and the photographs.
More About Domestic Violence Charges in Austin
These related pages cover other charges and questions that often come up after a family violence arrest.
- felony family violence charges: how other situations make an assault a felony case.
- assault on a pregnant person: the separate charge when the person who was hurt was pregnant.
- assault on an elderly person: how the age of the person alleged to be hurt changes the charge.
- family violence enhancements in Austin: how the family violence label changes an assault case.
- defending a domestic violence charge: the basic stages of a family violence case, from arrest to resolution.
- when the person won’t press charges: why the State, not the complainant, decides whether a case goes forward.
Why Austin Clients Choose Barton & Associates for Impeding Breath Defense
Barton & Associates has tried Texas cases since 2001. Our Austin criminal defense team includes Gary J. Barton, a former capital murder prosecutor who has tried more than 100 jury trials, and Jim Erickson, a senior trial attorney in the Austin office who has handled criminal defense since 1985 and has more than 250 jury verdicts in more than sixty Texas counties. An impeding breath case turns on medical records, recordings and credibility. Before we discuss a plea, we collect those records, have them reviewed by qualified experts when warranted and build the defense with trial in mind.
We cannot promise a result. What we can do is tell you what the statute requires, where the State’s proof looks strong or weak and what each choice risks, including the times when a plea makes sense. The first consultation is free and confidential. Our Austin office is at 316 W. 12th Street, Suite 400, Austin, Texas 78701, and we meet with clients there by appointment. You can get directions to our office before your visit. For the first meeting, bring what you can of the following, and call even if you cannot find everything.
- Booking papers, any charging document and the date you are due back in court
- Release terms, any emergency protection order or protective order, and any monitoring or reporting requirements
- Photographs of any injury to you, and any photographs or messages from the day of the incident
- Anything you know about the 911 call or what the officers said and did
- Medical records or paperwork for you or the other person, if you have them
- Names of people who may have seen or heard what happened
- Court papers from any earlier assault, family violence or protective order case, in any state, plus any custody or divorce papers
- A calendar of your key dates and deadlines
Frequently Asked Questions About Impeding Breath or Circulation in Austin
Is impeding breath or circulation a felony in Texas?
Yes, when it is charged under Section 22.01(b)(2)(B) of the Penal Code. It is a third-degree felony when the person who was allegedly impeded is in a family, household or dating relationship with the accused. Without that relationship, the same conduct is charged as an ordinary assault, and an assault causing bodily injury is a Class A misdemeanor unless another rule raises it.
What is the penalty for impeding breath or circulation?
A third-degree felony is punished by 2 to 10 years in prison and a possible $10,000 fine. An earlier conviction of a listed offense against a person in that kind of relationship moves the charge into the second-degree range of 2 to 20 years under Section 22.01(b-3). The State can also charge aggravated assault if it alleges serious bodily injury or a deadly weapon.
What does impeding breath or circulation mean?
The statute says impeding the normal breathing or circulation of the blood by applying pressure to the throat or neck, or by blocking the nose or mouth. Choking, strangling and covering someone’s nose or mouth are the usual examples. A shove, a hold on the arms or pressure on the chest does not fit those words, even if it frightened the person.
What does the State have to prove?
That you caused bodily injury, that you did so by one of the methods the statute names, that you acted intentionally, knowingly or recklessly and that the person was in a family, household or dating relationship with you. Identity is part of the burden too. Each part can be tested, and we begin with the relationship and with what the evidence shows about where and how the person was touched.
Can I be charged if there are no marks?
Yes. The statute asks whether breathing or circulation was impeded, not whether a mark was left, and pain can satisfy the bodily injury element. A lack of marks, photographs or medical treatment is still important evidence, and it often decides whether the State can prove the case.
Can I be convicted if I did not mean to?
Possibly. The statute reaches reckless conduct as well as intentional or knowing conduct, so the State need only show that you knew of and disregarded a substantial risk. An accident defense has to explain how the contact happened and why it was not reckless. Self-defense is a separate question that we also evaluate.
Is there a lighter penalty for a first offense?
The punishment range is unchanged, 2 to 10 years, but a first offense with no record opens more options. Deferred adjudication is not excluded for this offense by Article 42A.102, and community supervision from the court is not barred by the list in Article 42A.054, unless a deadly weapon finding is made. Those are possibilities, not promises, and the prosecutor’s position and the evidence decide what is realistic.
Could this become a misdemeanor assault instead?
Sometimes. A reduction to misdemeanor assault can follow when the evidence of impeding is weak, when the relationship element cannot be proved or when there are strong defenses. The prosecutor decides whether to offer it, and the plea can still carry a family violence finding. We review any offer against the whole case.
What if the other person wants to drop the charge?
The prosecutor decides, not the person who made the report. That person’s wishes can influence how the State sees the case, but they do not close it. Stay away from any discussion of the case with that person, since it can bring a new charge or be used as evidence.
How does an impeding breath charge affect custody?
An arrest is not a finding, but family violence matters in a custody case. Under Section 153.004 of the Family Code a court must weigh evidence of family violence, may not appoint both parents joint managers on credible proof of a pattern of abuse by one against the other, and can restrict possession. A pending criminal case should be coordinated with any custody case.
Will I lose my right to own a gun?
A felony conviction restricts firearm possession. Under Section 46.04(a) of the Penal Code, a person with a felony conviction commits an offense by having a firearm for five years after release from confinement or supervision, and later anywhere but the home. Federal law has its own rules, and a protective order can restrict firearms as well. Do not move or sell weapons before talking with a lawyer.
Can this charge be expunged or sealed?
A dismissal or an acquittal may open the door to expunction, but a conviction cannot be expunged. Nondisclosure after deferred adjudication is closed to offenses involving family violence and to cases with an affirmative family violence finding, so a completed deferred adjudication cannot be assumed to be sealable.
What should I bring to the first meeting about this charge?
Bring your booking papers, any charging document and your next court date. Add your release terms, any protective order and photos or messages from the day of the incident, plus medical records if you have them. Tell us about any earlier case in any state, and call even if the list is incomplete.
Talk With an Austin Impeding Breath or Circulation Attorney
Medical records and recordings can disappear and bond terms are set within hours, so the early days count. Contact a domestic violence lawyer in Austin at Barton & Associates to review the allegation, the evidence and our advice before you speak to anyone, sign anything or consider an offer.
Call our Austin office at 512-THE-FIRM (843-3476) or complete the online Free Consultation form to schedule a confidential meeting about the charge. Consultations at the office are by appointment only. The office is at 316 W. 12th Street, Suite 400, Austin, Texas 78701.
Main Category: Criminal Defense Austin
Practice Area Category: Domestic Violence
Barton & Associates, Attorneys at Law
316 W 12th St Suite 400, Austin, TX 78701
Office: 512-THE-FIRM (843-3476)