Legal Malpractice in San Antonio: Can You Sue Your Lawyer Under Texas Law?
Texas allows a client to sue a lawyer whose negligence caused a loss, but the claim is harder than most people expect. You must show what a reasonably prudent lawyer would have done, that your lawyer did not do it, and that you would have had a better result if the lawyer had. That last step means proving the value of the case you lost, which is why these claims are often called a case within a case. A negligence lawyer in San Antonio can review your file and tell you whether a claim exists. This page explains what Texas law requires, the two-year deadline and the narrow ways it can be extended, and what a successful claim can recover.
It applies if your lawyer missed a filing deadline, settled without your approval, failed to investigate or prepare, had a conflict of interest or mishandled your money, in a personal injury, family, business or criminal matter. If you were harmed by a doctor, nurse or hospital, different rules apply, and our guide to medical malpractice claims covers them.
What You Must Prove in a Texas Legal Malpractice Claim
A legal malpractice claim is a negligence claim against a lawyer. It requires a duty, a breach of that duty, damages and proximate cause (Cosgrove v. Grimes, Tex. 1989).
- Duty. The duty is owed to a client, so you generally must show an attorney-client relationship on the matter at issue. Whether one existed depends on what the lawyer and client said and did, not only on what either of them believed.
- Breach. The measure is what a reasonably prudent attorney would have done in the same or similar circumstances. A decision a reasonably prudent lawyer could have made is not negligence, even if it turned out badly.
- Proximate cause. You must show that the negligence caused your loss, which in a lawsuit usually means proving you would have obtained a better result without it. Texas requires that the negligence was a substantial factor and that the harm would not have occurred but for it (Rogers v. Zanetti, Tex. 2017).
- Damages. You must prove the amount of the loss, measured by the difference between the result you got and the result competent counsel would have obtained. If the lost result was a judgment, you must also show it would have been collectible, because a judgment against someone who could not pay has little value (Akin Gump v. National Development & Research Corp., Tex. 2009).
The Case Within a Case
In a claim over a lost or undervalued lawsuit, you are asked to prove what should have happened in the first matter: the evidence that should have been gathered, the claim that should have been filed on time, the settlement offer that should have been passed on to you. Courts usually re-create the original case to compare the result you got with the result competent counsel would have obtained, so the first lawyer’s file matters as much as the first lawyer’s conduct. The step is not always needed. When the harm does not depend on the merits of the first case, as in a claim over a missed settlement, the question becomes whether you would have accepted terms you could actually have met (Rogers v. Zanetti).
The Two-Year Deadline and How It Can Change
Texas courts apply the two-year period in Civil Practice and Remedies Code Section 16.003 to legal malpractice claims (Gray v. Skelton, Tex. 2020). The date the period starts is not always the date of the mistake, and several rules can move it.
- The discovery rule. Texas applies the discovery rule to legal malpractice, which can delay the start of the period until you knew or reasonably should have known of the wrongful act and your injury (Willis v. Maverick, Tex. 1988).
- Appeals of the original case. When the malpractice occurred in a matter that went to litigation, limitations is tolled until all appeals on the underlying claim are exhausted (Hughes v. Mahaney & Higgins, Tex. 1991). The Texas Supreme Court has kept that rule narrow. In Erikson v. Renda (Tex. 2019) it covered only the appeals in which the malpractice plaintiff took part.
- Criminal cases. For a former criminal defendant, limitations is tolled during direct appeals and post-conviction proceedings (Gray v. Skelton).
- Fee suits. If your former lawyer sues you, a counterclaim that arises from the same matter may be filed even if it would otherwise be late, but it must be filed no later than 30 days after your answer is due (Section 16.069).
Do not plan around an exception. Treat the date of the mistake as your deadline until a lawyer has confirmed that a later date applies to your facts.
Common Ways Lawyers Fail Clients
- Missed deadlines. Filing after the statute of limitations expires is the clearest example. A claim that is filed late can be barred however strong it was.
- Poor investigation and preparation. Not gathering key evidence, not interviewing witnesses, or not hiring an expert the case required.
- Pleading and procedural errors. Suing the wrong party, leaving out a required claim, missing a required notice, or missing a discovery deadline that costs you evidence.
- Settlement failures. Not telling you about an offer, settling without your approval, or advising you on the value of the case in a way no prudent lawyer would.
- Conflicts of interest. Representing people whose interests conflict, such as both spouses in a divorce or business partners on opposite sides of a dispute.
- Misuse of money and abandonment. Misusing funds held for a client, or dropping a case without protecting the client’s interests.
When a Bad Result Is Not Malpractice
Losing is not malpractice. Texas judges a lawyer’s choices by what a reasonably prudent attorney would have done with what was known at the time, and not by how the case ended. A strategy that failed, a settlement you now regret, or a reasonable judgment on an unsettled question of law may not be negligent. The question is whether a reasonably prudent lawyer would have made the same choice.
Most claims also need expert testimony. When the link between the lawyer’s conduct and the outcome is beyond a juror’s common understanding, an expert must explain, with a reasoned basis, why the conduct caused the loss, and a conclusion without that reasoning is not enough (Rogers v. Zanetti). The same is true of damages. An expert who values a lost claim must explain why it was worth the amount claimed (Elizondo v. Krist, Tex. 2013).
Criminal and Family Cases Raise Special Problems
- Criminal defense lawyers. A convicted defendant generally cannot sue defense counsel for malpractice unless the conviction has been set aside, whether on direct appeal, through post-conviction relief or otherwise (Peeler v. Hughes & Luce, Tex. 1995). If you are still contesting a conviction, the criminal case comes first and a malpractice claim waits on its outcome.
- Divorce and property division. After a decree is final, the court cannot change the division of property. It can enforce or clarify the decree, but it cannot alter the division (Family Code Section 9.007). Property the decree did not divide can be divided later in a separate suit (Section 9.201), which must be filed within two years after one former spouse clearly rejects the other’s ownership interest (Section 9.202). A mistake in the division itself is a different problem. The remedy may be a timely appeal or other post-judgment relief if it is still available, or a malpractice claim measured by what a properly prepared case would have produced.
What You Can Recover
- The value of the lost claim. The judgment or settlement you would have obtained, if it would have been collectible.
- Fees and expenses caused by the error. Fees you paid in the underlying matter, such as the cost of an appeal or a second lawyer, can be recovered to the extent the negligence caused them (Akin Gump v. National Development & Research Corp.).
- Forfeiture of fees. When a lawyer breaches a fiduciary duty, a Texas court can order the lawyer to give up some or all of the fee without proof of actual damages. The breach must be clear and serious, and the judge decides the amount (Burrow v. Arce, Tex. 1999).
- Exemplary damages. These are available only for fraud, malice or gross negligence proved by clear and convincing evidence, and the jury’s finding must be unanimous (Civil Practice and Remedies Code Section 41.003). Section 41.008 caps them at the greater of $200,000 or twice the economic damages plus up to $750,000 of noneconomic damages.
- What is not recoverable. The Texas Supreme Court has held that a client cannot recover mental anguish damages caused by economic losses from an attorney’s negligence (Douglas v. Delp, Tex. 1999).
The File and the Evidence
- Your file. Ask your former lawyer in writing for the complete file, including the engagement letter, pleadings, discovery, correspondence and billing records.
- Your communications with the lawyer. The lawyer-client privilege does not protect a communication that is relevant to a claim that the lawyer breached a duty to the client (Texas Rule of Evidence 503(d)(3)), so the emails and letters between you and the lawyer can be used to prove the claim, and to defend it.
- The record of the first case. Docket entries, filing dates, orders and transcripts show what was done and when.
- Proof of the lost result. Records, bills, contracts and expert opinions that show what the first case was worth.
- Proof of collectibility. The assets or insurance of the party who would have paid.
A State Bar Grievance Is Not a Malpractice Claim
You can report a lawyer to the State Bar of Texas. The Chief Disciplinary Counsel reviews each grievance to decide whether the conduct could be professional misconduct under the Texas Disciplinary Rules. The process cannot award damages or resolve fee disputes, and it does not change the result of your case. A violation of a disciplinary rule also does not by itself create a lawsuit or establish that the lawyer breached a legal duty to you, according to the rules’ own scope statement. A grievance and a lawsuit are separate, and a grievance does not stop the lawsuit deadline from running.
What This Means for Your Bexar County Case
- Write down the key dates: when you hired the lawyer, when the mistake happened and when you first learned of it.
- Ask your former lawyer in writing for your complete file, and keep copies of the engagement letter, bills, emails, filed papers and court orders.
- Find out what is still open in the original case, such as an appeal, a motion for a new trial or a post-conviction proceeding. Those deadlines run separately and are often short, so have a lawyer look at them right away.
- Do not sign a release, a fee settlement or a new agreement with your former lawyer or the lawyer’s insurer before your claim has been evaluated.
- If your former lawyer is suing you for fees, tell a lawyer immediately, because the deadline to bring a related counterclaim is 30 days after your answer is due.
- Treat the date of the mistake as your deadline until a lawyer confirms that a later date applies.
- Have a lawyer review the file for both the breach and the value of what you lost before you decide to sue. A claim that cannot show the lost result was better and collectible may not be worth filing.
More About Legal Malpractice and Related Claims
These guides cover related questions.
- Texas personal injury statute of limitations: how the two-year rule works for injury claims.
- Texas legal deadlines: other filing deadlines by type of claim.
Why San Antonio Clients Choose Barton & Associates for Legal Malpractice Claims
Barton & Associates has tried Texas cases since 2001. The firm’s trial attorneys include Gary J. Barton, who founded the firm after serving as a Bexar County prosecutor and has tried more than 100 cases to a jury, and Jim Erickson, a senior trial attorney who has tried more than 250 cases to a jury verdict. A malpractice claim is tried as two cases, so we start with the file: what the first lawyer did, what the record shows and what the result should have been. Then we tell you whether the claim looks viable, what it would take to prove and what each choice risks.
We cannot promise a result. What we can do is tell you what the statutes require, what we recommend and what each choice risks. The first consultation is free and confidential. Our San Antonio office is at 115 Camaron Street, San Antonio, Texas 78205. You can get directions to our office before your visit. For the first meeting, bring what you can of the following, and call even if you cannot find everything.
- The engagement letter or fee agreement, and your billing statements
- Your former lawyer’s file, if you have received it
- Pleadings, court orders, judgments and settlement papers from the original case
- Emails, letters and text messages with the lawyer
- Records that show the value of what you lost, such as bills, contracts or financial statements
- The name of the opposing party in the original case and any insurance information
- Any grievance response, fee demand or lawsuit from your former lawyer
- A calendar of your key dates and deadlines
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I sue my lawyer in Texas for bad representation?
Yes, if your lawyer was negligent and the negligence caused you a loss. A bad result alone is not enough. You must show that a reasonably prudent lawyer would have acted differently and that you would have been better off if your lawyer had (Cosgrove v. Grimes, Tex. 1989). We can review your file and tell you whether a claim exists.
What do I have to prove in a legal malpractice case?
A duty owed by the lawyer, a breach of that duty, damages and proximate cause. In practice the hardest element is causation: Texas requires that the negligence was a substantial factor in the loss and that the loss would not have occurred without it (Rogers v. Zanetti, Tex. 2017). You must also prove the amount of the loss.
What does case within a case mean?
It means proving what would have happened in the original matter if your lawyer had acted competently. If a lawsuit was lost, undervalued or never filed in time, the malpractice case asks what that lawsuit was worth. Courts usually re-create the original case to make the comparison, although a claim over a missed settlement turns instead on whether you would have accepted terms you could actually have met.
How long do I have to sue my lawyer in Texas?
Texas courts apply the two-year period in Civil Practice and Remedies Code Section 16.003 to legal malpractice claims (Gray v. Skelton, Tex. 2020). Under the discovery rule, the period can start later than the mistake, when you knew or reasonably should have known of the wrongful act and your injury (Willis v. Maverick, Tex. 1988). Treat the date of the mistake as your deadline until a lawyer confirms a later date applies to your facts.
Does an appeal or a post-conviction proceeding extend the deadline?
Sometimes. When the malpractice occurred in a case that went to litigation, limitations is tolled until all appeals on the underlying claim are exhausted (Hughes v. Mahaney & Higgins, Tex. 1991), but the Texas Supreme Court has kept that rule narrow and has limited it to appeals in which the malpractice plaintiff took part (Erikson v. Renda, Tex. 2019). For a former criminal defendant, limitations is tolled during direct appeals and post-conviction proceedings (Gray v. Skelton). Do not assume a pause without advice.
Is losing my case or a failed strategy malpractice?
Not by itself. Texas judges a lawyer’s decisions by what a reasonably prudent attorney would have done with what was known at the time. A choice that a reasonably prudent lawyer could have made is not negligence, even if it turned out badly (Cosgrove v. Grimes). A missed deadline, a failure to tell you about a settlement offer or a basic error of law is a different matter.
Do I need an expert witness to prove legal malpractice?
Often, yes. When the connection between the lawyer’s conduct and the outcome is beyond a juror’s common understanding, an expert must explain with a reasoned basis why the conduct caused the loss, and a bare conclusion is not enough (Rogers v. Zanetti). An expert who values a lost claim must also explain why it was worth the amount claimed (Elizondo v. Krist, Tex. 2013).
Can I sue my criminal defense lawyer?
Generally not while the conviction stands. A convicted defendant cannot sue defense counsel for malpractice unless the conviction has been set aside on direct appeal, through post-conviction relief or otherwise (Peeler v. Hughes & Luce, Tex. 1995). The Texas Supreme Court has held that limitations is tolled during direct appeals and post-conviction proceedings (Gray v. Skelton), so the claim is considered after those proceedings end.
Can a divorce decree be changed if my lawyer made a mistake?
Not by the divorce court once the decree is final. The court can enforce or clarify the decree, but it cannot change the division of property (Family Code Section 9.007). Property the decree did not divide can be divided in a separate suit (Section 9.201), and that suit has its own two-year limit (Section 9.202). A timely appeal or other post-judgment relief may be available for a mistake in the division, and a malpractice claim may be possible. Appeal and new trial deadlines are short, so ask a lawyer promptly.
What can I recover in a legal malpractice case?
The value of the claim you lost, if it would have been collectible, and the fees and expenses the negligence caused you to pay (Akin Gump v. National Development & Research Corp., Tex. 2009). If the lawyer breached a fiduciary duty, a court can order forfeiture of some or all of the fee, without proof of actual damages, for a clear and serious breach (Burrow v. Arce, Tex. 1999). Texas does not allow mental anguish damages caused by economic losses from an attorney’s negligence (Douglas v. Delp, Tex. 1999).
Can I get punitive damages from a lawyer who wronged me?
Only for fraud, malice or gross negligence proved by clear and convincing evidence, and the jury must be unanimous (Civil Practice and Remedies Code Section 41.003). Section 41.008 caps exemplary damages at the greater of $200,000 or twice the economic damages plus up to $750,000 of noneconomic damages. Ordinary negligence does not support them.
My former lawyer is suing me for unpaid fees. Can I bring a malpractice claim?
Possibly, as a counterclaim. A counterclaim arising from the same matter may be filed even if it would otherwise be late, but it must be filed no later than 30 days after your answer is due (Civil Practice and Remedies Code Section 16.069). Speak with a lawyer as soon as you are served so you do not miss that window.
What should I bring to the first meeting about a legal malpractice claim?
Bring the engagement letter and billing statements, your former lawyer’s file if you have it, the pleadings, orders and settlement papers from the original case, your emails and letters with the lawyer, records that show the value of what you lost, any fee demand or lawsuit from the lawyer, and a calendar of your key dates. Call even if some records are missing.
Talk With a San Antonio Legal Malpractice Attorney
The deadline may already be running, and your former lawyer’s insurer may be building its own file. Speak with a San Antonio negligence attorney at Barton & Associates before you sign anything or discuss your claim with your former lawyer.
Call our San Antonio office at 210-500-0000 or complete the online Free Consultation form to schedule a confidential meeting about your legal malpractice claim. The office is at 115 Camaron Street, San Antonio, Texas 78205.
Main Category: Personal Injury
Practice Area Category: Specialized Negligence
Barton & Associates, Attorneys at Law
115 Camaron St, San Antonio, TX 78205
Office: 210-500-0000